I tried 17 of Trader Joe's fall snacks, and I'd buy at least 11 of them again

Trader Joe's shopping cart filled with fall chips, snacks, and cookies
I tried all of the fall snack foods I could find at Trader Joe's to find some of the best picks.Paige Bennett
  • I tried all of the seasonal fall snacks I could find at Trader Joe's to see which are worth getting.

  • I love the pumpkin Joe-Joe's, Fall Harvest salsa, and pumpkin-spice batons.

  • Trader Joe's This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar bars and seasonal Greek yogurts didn't impress me.

Trader Joe's is known for having fun seasonal snack items, and it's especially beloved for its fall offerings.

There are sweet, salty, spicy, and savory items to suit all sorts of taste preferences, from pumpkin-flavored Joe-Joe's to a variety of autumnal chips and salsas.

I tried 17 of the many snacks Trader Joe's has launched for fall to see which are worth buying again and which can be skipped.

Trader Joe's pumpkin-spiced Teeny Tiny pretzels are adorable.

Trader Joe's pumpkin spiced. teeny pretzels in bag
Trader Joe's has a few varieties of Teeny Tiny pretzels.Paige Bennett

This autumnal iteration of Teeny Tiny pretzels from the chain has a yogurt-flavored coating and is topped with crushed pumpkin seeds.

The pretzels were far better than similar products I've tried.

pumpkin cream covered pretzels on white plate
I'd buy Trader Joe's pumpkin-spiced Teeny Tiny pretzels again.Paige Bennett

I really enjoyed these pretzels. I've tried similar yogurt-covered pretzels from other grocery stores, but these are the best I've tasted.

The first bite is sweet and crunchy from the yogurt and pumpkin seeds, but the final notes are slightly salty and spiced, like black pepper.

I especially enjoyed the bite-sized pieces with a thinner coating of yogurt.

The maple-flavored fudge smelled delicious.

Maple-flavored fudge box from trader joe's
I could smell maple through the package.Paige Bennett

Although I was initially disappointed by the small number of fudge pieces in this box, that feeling immediately went away as the delicious smell of maple came through the bag.

 

The fudge tasted fine, but the texture wasn't for me.

cube of maple-flavored fudge on white plate
The maple-flavored fudge had a crumbly texture.Paige Bennett

Although I expected dense, chewy, and, well, fudgy, this fudge was more hard and crumbly in texture. The texture wasn't great, but the buttery, maple flavor tasted just as good as it smelled.

The mini maple-flavored marshmallows seemed like they'd be great for fall baking.

trader joe's mini maple marshmallows
Mini marshmallows can be added to cookies or bars.Paige Bennett

I don't typically eat marshmallows because I'm a vegetarian and most kinds contain gelatin. Fortunately, the Trader Joe's maple-flavored mini marshmallows are labeled as vegan so I was excited to try them.

They didn't look very good, but they tasted great.

beige colored marshmallows in a bowl
I can't wait to use the mini maple-flavored marshmallows in my fall recipes.Paige Bennett

The marshmallows may not look all that appetizing with a beige color and wrinkly appearance, but I enjoyed their flavor.

The maple flavor was present but not overwhelming, and the marshmallows were chewy before melting in my mouth.

Trader Joe's maple-spiced nut mix features lots of variety.

Jar of Trader Joe's maple spiced nut mix
The mix had dried fruit and nuts.Paige Bennett

Trader Joe's maple-spiced nut mix promised flavors of maple- and rosemary-flavored almonds and pecans, along with black pepper, red pepper, dried cranberries, and pumpkin seeds.

I was surprised by the lack of flavor in the maple-spiced nut mix.

nuts in a small green bowl
The maple-spiced nut mix felt savory to me.Paige Bennett

This mix definitely leans more savory than sweet, a much-appreciated twist compared to many of the other sweet fall snacks.

Although I got hints of pepper, I didn't get much of the maple or rosemary flavors at all. I wished these nuts had a stronger flavor.

Trader Joe's rolled wafers are usually a hit for me, so I was excited to see a pumpkin-spice version.

author holding pumpkin spice baton in front of jar of batons
Trader Joe's rolled wafers come in a cylindrical container.Paige Bennett

Rolled wafers are a favorite snack of mine, so I figured I'd like this fall version with a pumpkin-spice filling.

 

 

The batons were a hit for me.

View inside of a trader joe's pumpkin spice baton stick
The wafers were nice and thin.Paige Bennett

The batons had a sweet, pumpkin flavor with a hint of spice. The texture was light and crisp at first, and as the wafer layers flaked away, I was left with a creamy coating in the center.

I tried the Honeycrisp-apple granola on its own and with yogurt.

Trader Joe's honeycrisp granola
Trader Joe's Honeycrisp-apple granola pairs well with yogurt.Paige Bennett

The granola came in pretty big, crunchy clusters, which were then contrasted by the chewy dried apple pieces. I tried this first on its own, and it was a big hit for me.

The apple flavor tasted natural, which I loved.

Granola on a white plate
Trader Joe's Honeycrisp-apple granola doesn't have an artificial flavor, in my opinion.Paige Bennett

I also tried this granola with the Honeycrisp-apple cinnamon Greek yogurt, and I loved the combination. It created a prominent sweet apple flavor balanced out by spices like cinnamon, cardamom, and black pepper.

Trader Joe's Honeycrisp-apple cinnamon Greek yogurt had a super thick texture.

Trader Joe's honey crisp apple cinnamon yogurt
The Honeycrisp yogurt had a lot of cinnamon throughout.Paige Bennett

Trader Joe's Honeycrisp-apple cinnamon Greek yogurt is made with whole milk and I found it had tiny, chewy pieces of apple throughout.

I also found this yogurt to be extremely thick.

The flavor was OK but I couldn't get past the thickness.

Spoon taking yogurt out of trader joe's apple cinnamon yogurt container
The Greek yogurt needed some granola to balance it out.Paige Bennett

The yogurt was OK on its own, although the texture was a little too thick for me.

A sprinkle of Honeycrisp-apple granola helped balance out the thick yogurt, so I'd only buy this again if I had the granola available.

I also picked up a pumpkin Greek nonfat yogurt.

Trader Joe's pumpkin greek yogurt
Trader Joe's Greek yogurt comes in one-serving containers.Paige Bennett

I found this light-orange yogurt was not nearly as thick as the apple-cinnamon variety I tried. I liked the texture better than the other yogurt, but not so much the flavor.

The pumpkin yogurt was one of my least favorite items of this taste test.

Spoonful of Trader Joe's pumpkin yogurt
The Greek yogurt wasn't sweet enough for me.Paige Bennett

I was expecting this yogurt to taste sweet, like many pumpkin fall foods, but it was actually very earthy and almost savory.

I wasn't expecting that flavor switch, and I didn't love it. I wouldn't buy this one again.

Trader Joe's apple-and-pumpkin hand pies can be heated in the oven.

Trader Joe's Apple and pumpkin handpies
Trader Joe's apple-and-pumpkin hand pies come in packs of two.Paige Bennett

I heated one of these pumpkin-and-apple-filled pies per package instructions — for 10 minutes at 350 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven.

The crust got golden but stayed buttery soft, so the hand pie felt prone to buckling as I held it to eat. Cutting it in half helped slightly.

The hand pies were better than I expected.

Pumpkin-shaped hand pie on plate
The hand pies seemed to have a pumpkin shape.Paige Bennett

I liked the combination of earthy, creamy pumpkin and sweet, chewy apples. Although I wish there were stronger flavors of cinnamon and other warming spices in the filling, I would buy these again.

Trader Joe's usually does a great job with its seasonal Joe-Joe's.

Box of Trader Joe's Pumpkin-flavored Joe-Joes
The pumpkin-flavored Joe-Joe's are a seasonal staple.Paige Bennett

Trader Joe's releases new Joe-Joe's with just about every season. Fortunately, these pumpkin sandwich cookies were delicious.

The pumpkin-flavored Joe-Joe's are a classic for good reason.

Pumpkin sandwich cookie in author's hand in front of box
The Joe-Joe's had plenty of creme.Paige Bennett

The pumpkin-spice flavor is strong but not overwhelming, and the cookies were nice and crisp yet buttery.

The filling was creamy and I found there was plenty of it, almost as much as I'd find in my favorite Double Stuf Oreos.

The maple-leaf cookies were quite large.

Trader Joe's maple leaf cookies box on black table
Trader Joe's maple-leaf cookies have a creme filling.Paige Bennett

The maple-leaf design of these cookies is so cute and I liked that they were sandwich cookies. Each maple-flavored-creme-filled cookie was much larger than I expected.

These cookies would pair perfectly with coffee.

Maple-leaf-shaped cookies on a plate
Trader Joe's maple-leaf cookies had a subtle maple flavor.Paige Bennett

The cookies had a more subtle fall flavor than the pumpkin Joe-Joe's, but they were still great.

I liked the buttery shortbread and light maple flavor. These would be perfect for dunking in milk or even coffee.

I didn't like the texture or flavor of Trader Joe's This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar cereal bars.

Trader Joe's this pumpkin walks into a bar box on black table
Trader Joe's This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar cereal bars come in boxes of six.Paige Bennett

Trader Joe's has a lot of iterations of cereal bars like these, but the pumpkin let me down.

Honestly, I didn't love the taste or texture of these bars. Even with the jammy center, they were too dry for me.

I'll try other flavors of these bars next time.

Trader Joe's pumpkin bar broken in half in author's hand above white plate
I didn't find much great flavor in the Trader Joe's This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar bars.Paige Bennett

In my opinion, the filling tasted more perfumy than pumpkiny. In just one bite, I knew these weren't for me.

Trader Joe's crispy potato snacks shaped like ghosts and bats were so fun.

Trader Joe's ghosts and bats crispy potato snacks
Trader Joe's Ghosts & Bats seemed like they could be a hit at a Halloween party.Paige Bennett

I was really impressed that the whole bag of the delicate bat- and ghost-shaped crisps hadn't turned to dust in transit to the store.

I liked the thin, crispy texture, but thought the flavor was bland.

White crispy potato chips with ghost faces in them on plate
Some of the crisps had tiny ghost faces.Paige Bennett

These crisps tasted like they were just made from a plain potato. If these had some sort of seasoning added, they would be a hit.

Because they're also too fragile to eat with a dip for added flavor, I wouldn't buy these again.

 

Trader Joe's pepita salsa brought some heat.

Jar of Trader Joe's pepita salsa
Trader Joe's pepita salsa comes in a 12-ounce jar.Paige Bennett

Alongside peppers and tomatoes, the star of Trader Joe's pepita salsa is pumpkin seeds. I found that the pepita flavor made this taste more like a typical salsa than a pumpkin-flavored fall snack.

I ended up really loving the pepita salsa.

Orange salsa in white ramekin
The pepita salsa seemed to have chunks of tomatoes and peppers.Paige Bennett

The pepita salsa had more of a medium spice level and a thick texture, which is what I prefer.

It was good with chips but the thicker texture also means it should work great for tacos and burritos.

Trader Joe's Fall Harvest salsa sounded unique.

Trader Joe's fall harvest salsa in jar
Trader Joe's Fall Harvest salsa pairs well with crunchy tortilla chips.Paige Bennett

Trader Joe's Fall Harvest salsa contains ingredients like bell peppers, onions, honey, apples, and butternut squash. Fortunately, the combo made for a unique, sweeter flavor.

I could taste hints of squash and apple in most bites and it was surprisingly enjoyable.

The watery salsa was sweet and delicious.

Liquidy brownish salsa in white ramekin
Trader Joe's Fall Harvest salsa is a bit too watery for my liking.Paige Bennett

This salsa was very mild, so I might mix in extra chopped peppers when I serve it in the future to add more heat to balance out the sweetness.

The only real downside for me was the super thin, watery texture. It made it hard to scoop up a generous portion of salsa with chips.

Trader Joe's leaf-shaped corn tortilla chips looked great in the bag.

Trader Joe's fall leaf-shaped tortilla chips in bag with few on plate in front of bag
Trader Joe's leaf-shaped corn tortilla chips are orange and red.Paige Bennett

The leaf chips tasted like classic tortilla chips, and they had a good amount of salt for seasoning.

The chips' flavor isn't anything special, but they're very fun.

Bag of leaf-shaped tortilla chips with author holding one chip in front of bag
The leaf chips reminded me of standard corn tortilla chips.Paige Bennett

Because these were similar to typical tortilla chips, they were unsurprisingly delicious when paired with both Trader Joe's pepita and Fall Harvest salsas.

I was skeptical about Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chips at first.

Bag of Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chips with plate of chips in front of bag
I wasn't sure abut Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chips at first.Paige Bennett

I wasn't sure that I would like these autumnal chips, as it seemed weird to have warming spices in tortilla chips.

 

Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chips paired well with the Fall Harvest salsa.

Author holding Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chip in front of bag
Trader Joe's pumpkin tortilla chips have a solid crunch.Paige Bennett

I liked the slight sweetness the chips had to balance out the salt they were topped with. They were delicious and I found they paired especially well with the Fall Harvest salsa because it's also quite sweet.

Read the original article on Insider