Seafood group 'red list' urges buyers to avoid lobster
Sep. 6—American lobster is now on a "red list" of seafood to be avoided because of the risks lobster fisheries pose to endangered North Atlantic right whales, according to Seafood Watch, a sustainable seafood advocacy group.
Members of the Maine lobster industry are "extremely disappointed" with the listing, saying it does not take into account the many changes that the industry has enacted to protect whales.
"Lobster is one of the most sustainable fisheries in the world due to the effective stewardship practices handed down through generations of lobstermen," said Patrice McCarron, executive director of the Maine Lobsterman's Association. "These include strict protections for both the lobster resource and right whales."
Gov. Janet Mills said Tuesday that the label is "flat out wrong."
"(The designation) sends the wrong message about Maine lobster, and it insults thousands of hardworking lobstermen who risk their lives to put food on the table while practicing responsible stewardship and taking action to protect whales," she said. "Consumers and businesses must see through this list and recognize that lobstermen are partners in conservation and sustainability and that the delicious Maine lobster can and should continue to be enjoyed."
The red list is meant to alert consumers that the seafood is farmed in ways that have a high risk of harming wildlife or the environment. Seafood Watch, a project of the Monterey Bay Aquarium in California, partners with restaurants, distributors and grocery stores, while maintaining formal partnerships with major seafood buyers that include Aramark, Bon Appetit, Cheesecake Factory and Whole Foods. The buyers often use the listings to guide purchasing and menu choices and to avoid red-listed seafood.
Seafood Watch added to the list 14 species that use gear with vertical lines, such as pots, traps or gillnets, which are known to entangle whales. Entanglement in fishing gear has been shown to be the leading cause of death and serious injury of the endangered North Atlantic right whale. It is estimated that fewer than 340 of the whales remain.
No whale entanglements have been linked to Maine fishermen, though a lack of state-specific gear marking in the past made it difficult to determine where many entanglements occurred.
The organization said in a news release that Canadian and U.S. management measures do not do enough to reduce entanglement risk and promote the recovery of the right whale population. As a result it downgraded the ratings for fisheries that use pots, traps and gillnets within the right whale's range. The U.S. Jonah crab fishery also was downgraded to red for this reason, as was the Gulf of Maine flounder fishery and the offshore U.S. Atlantic croaker fishery.
Baxter Key, a co-owner of The Highroller Lobster Co. in Portland, a popular restaurant where lobster features prominently on the menu, said he has never personally heard a customer ask about Seafood Watch ratings, and that the announcement of the red-listing puzzled him.
"As far as I understood, practices were being put into place to make lobster fishing less of a danger to right whales," he said. "The majority of entanglements have been for the north and Canada, where the laws are different, so it seems like we're already being pretty proactive in the preservation of them in my opinion. Obviously, I don't want right whales to get hurt or go extinct, because they are a vital part of our ecosystem, but I do think there's a balance to be struck."
Seafood Watch cites a "North Atlantic right whale report card" by scientists at the New England Aquarium and by Richard Pace, the lead scientist who developed the model used to estimate the number of the whales remaining.
Data shows, and Maine lobstermen have long argued, that right whales no longer use waters off the coast of Maine as a feeding ground and have shifted to the northeast in search of food. The report card also states that right whale distributions are changing, listing the southeastern U.S., southern New England, Cape Cod Bay, the Gulf of St. Lawrence and other locations among the emerging habitats.
"The drastic shifts in right whale distribution, both temporally and spatially, and the speed at which they occurred, should be viewed as an indicator of the inadequacy of static mitigation efforts focused solely on past habitat use," the report states.
Nevertheless, Seafood Watch states that because only 12 percent of entanglements can be linked to a specific location, "all of the fisheries using this gear are considered a risk."
A spokesman for the seafood restaurant chain Red Lobster disagrees with this assessment.
"We recognize that there are divergent interpretations of unknown impacts related to North Atlantic Right Whales," the spokesperson said. "It is important to note that the specific source causing most of the North Atlantic right whale deaths remains uncertain, but in the cases where a source can be identified, there has been a significant and meaningful decline in those attributable to the Maine lobster fishery. Thus, we find it misleading to suggest to consumers that avoiding Maine lobster would benefit whale preservation efforts."
Another factor that contributed to the changed designation was a July 2022 court ruling that NOAA's regulations of the lobster industry violate the Endangered Species Act and the Marine Mammal Protection Act for failing to reduce risk to right whales fast enough.
New regulations that went into effect in May, which require weakened ropes, increased numbers of traps per vertical line, and seasonal closures in certain areas, attempt to bring the whales' risk of entanglement to below a number known as the "potential biological removal rate," or how many whales could be seriously injured or killed per year without driving the population to unsustainable levels. In calculations that have been the subject of lawsuits, the National Marine Fisheries Service determined this number was 0.7 whales per year and projected that U.S. lobster fishery would potentially continue to kill whales at a rate three times that in the coming years.
Oceana, a nonprofit committed to protecting the world's oceans, applauded the red-listing and is calling on the federal government to implement stronger measures to protect North Atlantic right whales.
"It's unfortunate that the government's failure to update the safeguards to protect North Atlantic right whales is having such serious consequences on these fisheries," said Gib Brogan, campaign director for Oceana. "Every vertical fishing line and gillnet is a threat to the remaining North Atlantic right whales, which face the risk of entanglements every day. To give this species a fighting chance, the agency must reduce the number of vertical lines and gillnets in the water and transition the fishery to whale-safe fishing gear. Fishery managers must increase protections to save North Atlantic right whales so seafood retailers, consumers and restaurants can put American lobster and crab back on the menu."
Maine Lobster Marketing Collaborative's executive director, Marianne LaCroix, disagrees. A recent marketing video the group developed emphasizes the industry's participation in developing with regulators measures to reduce entanglement risk to right whales.
"Maine Lobster is one of the most sustainable seafoods in the world, harvested with care and dedication by people that have steadfastly sought to protect the health of the lobster stock and the vitality of the marine environment," she said. "Monterey Bay Aquarium's decision ignores the industry's long history of adapting gear and fishing practices to protect North Atlantic right whales and undermines the newly enacted federal regulations designed to provide additional protections. ... Industry members will continue to closely collaborate with a range of stakeholders — from policymakers and regulators to scientists and advocates — to ensure that Maine Lobster remains a locally sourced sustainable product, enjoyed by millions of global consumers, caught by fishermen committed to doing things the right way."
